cabal-helper alternatives and similar packages
Based on the "cabal" category
Do you think we are missing an alternative of cabal-helper or a related project?
In the Haskell ecosystem the most widely used build system is
Cabal library, not to be
confused with the
cabal build tool which is usually refered to by it's
cabal-install to disambiguate.
All contemporary meta build tools such as
stack as well as some
custom Haskell build systems use the
Cabal library as their
foundation. For example the Glasgow Haskell Compiler's bespoke GNU Make based
build system also utilises the
Cabal library at its core.
We capitalize on this fact by using build information
Cabal writes to disk as
the common denominator between all Haskell build tools. This allows us to
easily support a variety of build tools without incuring significant
Haskell Packages and
Essentially all Haskell packages implement
"The Haskell Cabal" (pdf)
packaging specification. The
Cabal library and
cabal-install build tool
are named after this specification. Yes we really love confusing naming in
The specification revolves around this
Setup.hs script file you might
have seen before. Basically the idea is a Haskell source package consists
of, at the very least, a
Setup.hs file, which is a Haskell program that
provides a well defined command-line interface for configuring, building
and installing it. Haskell developers can use build tools, such as
cabal, which interface with
Setup.hs and provide functionality on top
Note that even though originally packages were meant to be free to
Setup.hs interface however they like, this hasn't been
supported by build tools for a long time. In practice use of the
Setup.hs is mandatory.
Now, the first step of building a package in "The Haskell Cabal" is to call
$ runhaskell Setup.hs configure
Setup.hs the default behaviour of the
Cabal library is to
first read the
<pkg-name>.cabal configuration file to determine how the
project is structured and what dependencies it has. In the case of
configure it will then probe the system it's running on about:
- the list of available Haskell packages,
- system package dependencies (using pkg-config) and
- Haskell compiler type, version and supported language extensions (among other things).
Finally Haskell package dependency resolution is also run.
Cabal then writes all the gathered information on the concrete
configuration of the package into a file called
steps, such as
runhaskell Setup.hs build, will then read this state file
<package-name>.cabal to avoid having to probe the system or
run dependency resolution again.
It is this file that
cabal-helper is primarily concerned with reading and
presenting in a usable manner. Reading this file essentially means that all
the complicated work has already been done for us and we can get straight
to running the compiler.
So far so good. That's pretty much the end of the story for the traditional
cabal build commands but what about
cabal new-build and Stack I hear
Well, essentially both new-build and Stack simply build on top of the
Setup.hs interface. So the
setup-config file is still there
in all it's glory, we just have to deal with more than one of it since both
build-tools support multiple packages and
Setup.hs only knows how to deal
with a single package at a time.
To support this cabal-helper has grown a representation of what a project is in it's API starting with the 1.0 series. We currently support both new-build and Stack. The API is designed to allow extending support to custom build systems such as GHC's but we have not done this yet.
The "Helper" in cabal-helper
In the API docs you will find frequent mentions of "the helper executable" so I'll explain what that is here because it is quite fundamental to how things work in the codebase.
The fundamental problem cabal-helper solves is the fact that in order to
access the data Cabal stores in the
setup-config file we have to link
lib:Cabal. However the binary format of this file is unstable and
there is no backwards compatibility mechanism in the library. So to read a
setup-config file produced by a certain version of Cabal we have to link
against exactly that version.
Not only that but usally the
cabal commandline tool controls which Cabal
library version is used, so we really just have to deal with whatever we
To solve this problem the cabal-helper library builds a small executable at
runtime who's only purpose is to link against
lib:Cabal, read the
setup-config and present the data there in a Cabal version
independent format for consumption by the cabal-helper library.
Recently some work was merged into cabal to have
Setup.hs to do this
natively (https://github.com/haskell/cabal/pull/5954), we're planning to
use this eventually to replace our "helper".
If you have any problems, suggestions, comments swing by #ghc-mod (web client) on Freenode. If you're reporting a bug please also create an issue here so we have a way to contact you if you don't have time to stay.
Do hang around for a while if no one answers and repeat your question if you still haven't gotten any answer after a day or so. You're most likely to get an answer during the day in GMT+1.